Adult acne, much like teenage, is incredibly common and can be difficult to treat. This is because it has a number of drivers which often need more than one type of treatment approach. To make things worse, acne itself can change from time to time depending on which driver is predominant and external triggers. So, treatment often involves a lot of trial and error with different products, medications or procedures. Spironolactone and doxycycline are two popular medicines for adult acne which often trend in the acne skin world. However, they’re too often grouped together even though they address different problems and have different uses. In this article, we compare the actions and appropriate uses of spironolactone vs doxycycline for adult acne.
What is Adult Acne?
Adult acne is not simply teenage acne that never went away. It is a distinct clinical pattern of breakouts that develops for the first time or persists beyond the age of 25. There is often combination of drivers such as hormonal signalling, inflammation and changes in skin barrier function. Adult acne typically presents differently to teenage acne. So instead of widespread blackheads and pustules, adult acne tends to cluster along the lower face, jawline, chin and neck. It also often flares cyclically and lingers longer than expected. Lesions may also be frequently deeper, more inflamed and slower to heal. This increases the risk of post-inflammatory pigmentation and scarring.
Because the underlying drivers vary, treatment is not a simple escalation of one product from mild to strong. Most patients require a combination approach that targets the acne causing bacteria, inflammation, clogged pores and hormonal signalling. As you can imagine, this usually requires more than one treatment types. In addition to common ingredients such as retinoids like tretinoin or roaccutane, azelaic acid and benzoyl peroxide, medications such as doxycycline and spironolactone are sometimes useful. Each of these has different actions and uses. Understanding the dominant driver(s) behind your acne is what determines which treatment(s) will work.
How Does Doxycycline Work?
Doxycycline is an oral antibiotic, but its value in acne treatment is not primarily antibacterial. It also has a vital anti-inflammatory role. In the skin, it kills acne causing bacteria and suppresses the inflammatory response triggered by Cutibacterium acnes. This is why it can lead to a noticeable reduction in redness, tenderness and swelling within weeks. However, doxycycline does not alter the underlying behaviour of adult acne. It does not reduce sebum (oil) production, change sensitivity to androgen hormones nor does it prevent follicles from becoming blocked in the first place. Once the medication is withdrawn, those drivers remain fully intact. For this reason, doxycycline should not be viewed as a disease-modifying treatment. It functions as treatment for active inflammatory acne breakouts.
How Does Spironolactone Work?
In acne, spironolactone works by reducing the effect of androgens on the skin. It is available off-label orally where it acts systemically or topically where it works just at the level of the skin. In adult acne, particularly in women with hormonally driven breakouts, the issue is rarely excess hormone production. It is heightened androgen sensitivity within the sebaceous unit (basically the oil producing bits of the pores).
Spironolactone blunts that signal. By blocking androgen receptors and reducing downstream sebum production, spironolactone alters the environment that allows acne to form. Less oil means less pore clogging, bacterial over growth and secondary inflammation. It is in effect a disease-modifying treatment that changes the conditions that allow adult acne to persist in the first place. Because spironolactone targets a driver of acne rather than the breakouts, results are not immediate. Improvement typically unfolds over several months as the baseline behaviour of the skin gradually changes.
When to Use Spironolactone vs Doxycline for Acne?
The most useful way to compare spironolactone vs doxycycline is by asking what problem you are trying to solve. These medications act at different points in the acne pathway and are prescribed for different reasons. Doxycycline acts downstream to kill the acne causing bacteria and suppress inflammation. The main uses of doxcyline are when there is:
- Actively inflamed, painful or widespread acne
- Rapid reduction in redness and tenderness
- A need for short-term control in order as a bridge to introduce other treatments
In these cases, doxycycline can settle active disease, but it does not alter the underlying drivers and hence the chance of acne recurring once stopped is high. Spironolactone acts upstream by blocking androgen hormone activity in the skin. For this reason, spironolactone is most useful when:
- There is clear evidence of hormonal sensitivity (e.g. lower face acne that is cyclical)
- Acne is not responding well to traditional treatments like retinoids or antibiotics
- The intention is to use it long term alongside other treatments that tackle active breakouts and help with existing scars or hyperpigmentation
The main benefit of spironolactone is to reduce the conditions that allow acne to recur. However, it is not useful by itself as it can’t handle non hormone drivers of acne or post acne scars or marks.
What are the Risks of Using Spironolactone or Doxycline for Acne?
Both spironolactone and doxycycline can be effective in the right context, but each comes with specific limitations. Understanding these is essential, not only for safety, but to avoid using the right medication for the wrong problem. Firstly, they’re both prescription only medicines. Also, neither of them are safe for use in pregnancy or during breastfeeding.
Doxycycline is not designed for long-term use in acne due to a number of side effects. Additionally, its benefits are typically temporary. Once the medication is stopped, acne often returns. Beyond this there are a number of other potential risks of using doxycycline which include:
- Risk of antibiotic resistance with repeated or prolonged courses
- Increasing susceptibility to sun damage
- Disruption of the gut and skin microbiome
- Gastrointestinal side effects such and nausea and throat irritation
Spironolactone requires even more careful patient selection vs doxycycline. It is not suitable for people with kidney or heart problems. As it alters hormonal signalling, its effects are slower. It can however be used long term and requires ongoing use if hormonal drives persist. That said, it also carries a few potential risks including:
- Menstrual irregularities (particularly when taken orally at higher doses)
- Breast tenderness or fluid shifts in some patients
- Need for appropriate screening and monitoring of potassium levels and kidney function especially if used orally
From a clinical perspective, it’s a bit silly to compare spironolactone vs doxycycline. These two medications can never be interchangeable as they tackle different completely different drivers and stages of acne. They’re also not the only acne treatments. Doxycline or spironolactone often require use alongside other acne treatments or even together. As with everything in skincare, there is no one size fits all approach. Acne is a chronic skin condition that requires a thoughtful and individual approach for each person.
At City Skin clinic, we are super passionate about personalised skincare. Our virtual skin clinic offers safe and effective custom skin treatments. Where appropriate our doctors use ingredients such as Tretinoin, Hydroquinone and Spironolactone to treat skin conditions like acne, hyperpigmentation, melasma and skin ageing. Start your online consultation today. The journey towards great skin starts here.
This article is intended for general informational purposes only and is not a substitute for medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. Always consult a qualified medical provider for any medical concerns or questions you might have.
